Steve Silber

May 5, 2005

                                                                                                           

 

Camouflage & Perception

 

How it works

 

 

 

 

 

 

Introduction

In nature, every advantage increases an animal's chances of survival, and therefore its chances of reproducing.  This simple fact has caused animal species to evolve a number of special camouflage adaptations that help them find food and keep them from becoming food.  Often, animals blend in with their environment so that they might be overlooked.  Other coloration or skin adaptations work specifically in relation to an animals behavioral patterns and only function correctly when used in combination with certain actions or behaviors.  Other animals don't hide at all, but throw predators off by disguising themselves as something dangerous or uninteresting.  All of these adaptations occur based on the processes inherent in the vision of and the vision capabilities of their specific predators/prey.

 

 

Concealing Colors

Most animal species in the world have developed some sort of natural camouflage using concealing colors that help them find food or avoid attack.  This camouflage varies considerably from species to species.  An animal's environment is often the most important factor in what the camouflage looks like.  The simplest camouflage technique is for an animal to match the "background" of its surroundings.  This usually does not simply mean a solid color that matches the color of; say a leaf it is often found near.  As the Craik-OÕBrien illusion[1] teaches us, we know that vision works by seeing outlines.  We know a dog when we see one, not by its color as much as by its shape.  An animal may have a variety of colors or just one color.  This is less significant than the ultimate goal of most camouflage.  What matters most is to break up the outline.  We see this in the example of the Narrow-Headed Frog.  This animal is multi colored in a similar pattern to the natural environment in which it is found.  This causes the eye of its predators to break up the outline of the shape of the frog, and instead see various shapes, which have no relationship to a living creature.  Instead this frog looks like a part of a rock with some mud on it.


 

Photo by David Parks

Paradoxophyla palmata, a Narrow-Headed Frog native to Madagascar. The frog's brown and yellow coloring, as well as its rough texture, allows it to blend in with the mud and tree trunks in its environment.

 

 

Photo by Carl Ressler

A Tartan Hawkfish, photographed off the coast of Papua New Guinea - The fish's striking coloration allows it to blend in with these bright gorgonian fans.


For most animals, "blending in" is the most effective approach of camouflage. You can see this everywhere.  Deer, squirrels, hedgehogs and many other animals have brownish, "earth tone" colors that match the brown of the trees and soil at the forest ground level.  Unlike the Narrow-Headed Frog, these animals have less of a specific color pattern against which it is silhouetted; therefore its coloration must be less specific to work in a variety of situations.  Still, there are often colorations, which help to break up their outline.  Some examples include the white tailed dear or Elk, both of which have light colorations on their backsides in order to break up their outline.  Sharks, dolphins and many other sea creatures have a grayish-blue coloring, which helps them blend in with the soft light underwater.  As light penetrates the water the change in medium causes refraction[2] and dispersion.[3]  The resulting light in the ocean is somewhat bluer. 

 

 

 

 

As we know through studies of color mixing, color subtraction properties, within this type of environment, make an animal of the same color difficult to see.[4]  Also many of these animals have lighter underbellies to compensate for the broadband spectrum of wavelengths seen when looking upwards towards the surface and sunlight.

 

Another trick of the camouflager is counter-shading.  This occurs when the coloration of the upper parts of an animal is darker than itÕs undersides.  Hence the effect of sunlight is counteracted.  As more saturated broadband white light shines on the animals back, its darker back absorbs more of the light so as not to be as light in appearance.  The underbelly, which receives little direct sunlight, does not need as much compensation to reduce its glare.  Also the normal casting of its shadow on the ground is distorted because more light is reflected on the ground underneath the animal, due to its light colored underside and it is less likely to be given away by its shadow.  Other benefits to a lighter underbelly in a hot climate are to absorb less light and allow the animal to remain cooler, and to repel ticks and fleas, which tend to avoid light or white areas.

 

The means of an animalsÕ coloration depends on its physiology.  In most mammals, the camouflage coloration is in the fur, since this is the outermost layer of the body.  In reptiles, amphibians and fish, it is in the scales; in birds it is in the feathers; and in insects it is part of the exoskeleton.  The actual structure of the outer covering may also evolve to create better camouflage.  In squirrels, for example, the fur is fairly rough and uneven, so it resembles the texture of tree bark. Many insects have a shell that replicates the smooth texture of leaves.

 

Photo by David Parks

A cryptic frog - This species has developed a coloring, texture and form that are similar to the leaves found in its environment.

 

 

 

 

 

Animals produce their colors using chromatophores.  There are two different types of chromatophores, biochromes and schematochromes. [5]  Biochromes, which are microscopic, natural pigments in an animal's body, produce colors chemically.  Their chemical makeup is such that they absorb some wavelengths of light and reflect others.  The apparent color of a pigment is a combination of all the visible wavelengths of light that are reflected by that pigment.  The other fascinating, but less common way for an animal to produce colors is via microscopic physical structures, called schematochromes. 

 

 

 

 

Essentially, these structures act like prisms, refracting and scattering visible light so that a certain combination of colors are reflected.[6]  Polar bears, for example, actually have black skin but appear white because they have translucent hairs.  When light shines on the hairs, each hair bends the light rays a little bit.  This bounces the light around from hair to hair so that some light makes it to the surface of the black skin, which absorbs the energy/heat (good for conserving energy to keep warm in cold artic climates), and the rest of it is deflected back out, producing the effect of white coloration.  Actually a polar bear looks a little yellowish compared to the white snow it is often around.  An explanation could be that a slightly larger percentage of wavelengths released are those in the mid-range hence the yellowish (albeit very unsaturated) appearance.

 

 

Photos by Feenicks

Polar Bears can appear yellowish to a snow-white color, depending on the time of day and the color of its background.[7]

 

 

 

In some animals, the two types of coloration are combined.  For example, reptiles, amphibians and fish with green coloration typically have a layer of skin with yellow pigment and a layer of skin that scatters and reflects light.  As discussed earlier most of the light in this environment is in the blue and green area of the spectrum.  Through this strange combination of additive and subtractive color mixing, these layers of skin often produce a grayish-green.

 

 

 

 

Color Change

Of course, an animal's surroundings may change from time to time.  Many animals have developed special adaptations that let them change their coloration as their surroundings change.  One of the biggest shifts in an animal's surroundings occurs with the changing of seasons.  In the spring and summer, a mammal's habitat might be full of greens and browns, while in the fall and winter; everything can be covered with snow.  While brown coloration is perfect for a summer-wooded environment, it makes an animal an easy target against a white background.  Many birds and mammals deal with this by producing different colors of fur or feathers depending on the time of year. In most cases, either changing amounts of daylight or shifts in temperature trigger a hormonal reaction in the animal that causes it to produce different biochromes.

 

Feathers and fur in animals are like human hair and fingernails -- they are actually dead tissue.  They are attached to the animal, but since they are not alive, the animal can do nothing to alter their composition.  Consequently, a bird or mammal has to produce a whole new coat of fur or feathers in order to change color.  Many animals can switch the coloring agent in the hair follicle on and off -- so in the summer, the hair is pigmented brown with melanin[8], but in the winter it is not pigmented, leaving the hair white.

 

 

 

 

 

Photo by David Parks

As the seasons change, the Arctic fox changes the color of its coat. In the spring and summer, it has a dark coat, to match the brown dirt in its environment. In the fall and winter, it turns white, to match the surrounding snow.

 

In many reptiles, amphibians and fish, on the other hand, coloration is determined by biochromes in living cells.  Biochromes may be in cells at the skin's surface or in cells at deeper levels.  These deeper-level cells are called chromatophores.  Some animals, such as various cuttlefish species, can manipulate their chromatophores to change their overall skin color.  These animals have a collection of chromatophores, each of which contains a single pigment.  An individual chromatophore is surrounded by a circular muscle that can constrict and expand.  When the cuttlefish constricts the muscle, all the pigment is squeezed to the top of the chromatophore. At the top, the cell is flattened out into a wide disc. When the muscle relaxes, the cell returns to its natural shape of a relatively small blob. This blob is much harder to see than the wide disc of the constricted cell.  By constricting all the chromatophores with a certain pigment and relaxing all the ones with other pigments, the animal can change the overall color of its body.[9] 

 

 


Using partitive color mixing[10], Cuttlefish with this ability can generate a wide range of colors and many interesting patterns.  By perceiving the color of a backdrop and constricting the right combination of chromatophores, the animal can blend in with all sorts of surroundings. Cuttlefish may also use this ability to communicate with each other.

 

Another animal that communicates through use of visual color cues is the most famous color-changer, the chameleon.  Chameleons alter their skin color using a similar mechanism as Cuttlefish, but not usually for camouflaging purposes. Chameleons tend to change their skin color when their mood changes.  This is controlled by hormone balances, not intentional muscular control or as a direct reaction to moving into different surroundings.

Photo by David Parks

Chamaeleo pardalis, a chameleon species found in the forests of Madagascar. Chameleons can produce a wide range of colors and patterns on their skin, but they do this primarily to express mood, not to blend in with different environments.


 

Photos by Wernher Krutein

Nudibranchs are marine snails (Gastropod Molluscs) that have no shell at maturity.[11]

 

Some animal species actually change which pigments are in their skin.  Nudibranchs, a small sea creature change their coloration by altering their diet.  When a nudibranch feeds from a particular sort of coral, its body deposits the pigments from that coral in the skin and outer extensions of the intestines.  The pigments show through, and the animal becomes the same color as the coral. Since the coral is not only the creature's food, but also its habitat, the coloration is perfect camouflage.  When the creature moves on to a differently colored piece of coral, its body color changes with the new food source.  Similarly, some parasite species, such as the fluke, will take on the color of their host, which is also their home.

 

The FlamingoÕs coloration is effected by its food intake as well, but not for camouflage.  A Flamingo eats plankton, using baleen.  Much like a whale, it uses barbs on itÕs long tongue to strain plankton through the baleen and down its throat.  The amount of pink coloration of a Flamingo is directly related to the amount of plankton it is able to eat.  The more Plankton it eats, the pinker it becomes, and the more likely it will be selected to reproduce.

 

This type of cultural appearance effecting behavior is widely known to humans.  For example, would-be heroes of ancient Greece used harsh soaps and bleaches to lighten and redden their hair to the color that was identified with honor and courage. First-century Romans preferred dark hair, which was made so by a dye concocted from boiled walnuts and leeks.  Today, hair coloring remains an important part of our culture, with a booming 75 percent of American women reportedly coloring their hair.  Women have also decided that blondes don't necessarily "Have more fun!"  Red is currently the most requested color at beauty salons.  And women aren't alone, men increasingly cover gray or, completely change their look.  Men's home hair-color sales reached $113.5 million last year, a 50 percent increase in just five years.

 

 

The Element of Disguise

In addition to background-matching coloration, many animals have distinctive designs on their bodies that serve to conceal them. These designs, which might be spots, stripes or a group of patches, can help the animal in a couple of ways. First, they may match the pattern of "the model," the background of the animal's surroundings. For example, animals that inhabit areas with tall, vertical grass often have long, vertical stripes. Second, they may serve as visual disruptions. Usually, the patterns are positioned "out-of-lineÓ with the body's contours. That is, the pattern seems to be a separate design superimposed on top of the animal. This makes it hard for the predator to get a clear sense of where the animal begins and ends -- the pattern on the body seems to run off in every direction.

 

The pattern of contrasting shapes and forms that make up the distinctive stripes on the coat of the zebra serve this purpose.  When looking from a distance the eye has difficulty in fitting a broken color form into one solid form.  Rather it will have a tendency to view the light patches between the dark stripes as the patches of light visible between grass and trees.  So it is possible for the zebra to merge into the grasslands and become invisible.

 

This disruptive coloration is particularly effective when animals in a species are grouped together.  To a lion, a herd of zebras doesn't look like a whole bunch of individual animals, but more like a big, striped mass.  The vertical stripes all seem to run together, making it hard for a lion to stalk and attack one specific zebra.  The stripes may also help a single zebra hide in areas of tall grass.  To humans, a zebra's stripes stick out like a sore thumb, so it's hard to imagine that the stripes act as camouflage, but because lions are colorblind, it doesn't matter that the zebra and surrounding environment are completely different colors.

 

Zoologists believe stripes offer zebras protection from predators in a couple of different ways.  The first is as simple pattern-camouflage, much like the type the military uses in its fatigue design.  The wavy lines of a zebra blend in with the wavy lines of the tall grass around it. It doesn't matter that the zebra's stripes are black and white and the lines of the grass are yellow, brown or green, because the zebra's main predator, is colorblind.  The pattern of the camouflage is much more important than its color, when hiding from these predators.  If a zebra is standing still in matching surroundings, a lion may overlook it completely.

 

This benefit may help an individual zebra in some situations, but the more significant means of protection has to do with zebra herds.  Zebras usually travel in large groups, in which they stay very close to one another.  The pattern of each zebra's stripes blends in with the stripes of the zebras around it.  This is confusing to the lion, which sees a large, moving, striped mass instead of many individual zebras. The lion has trouble picking out any one zebra, and so it doesn't have a very good plan of attack.  It's hard for the lion to even recognize which way each zebra is moving.  The lion's inability to distinguish zebras also makes it more difficult for it to target and track weaker zebras in the herd.

Photo by Steve Silber

When Zebras stand together, their stripes tend to blend into one another, making it difficult to distinguish one from the other.

 

 

Generally, this sort of camouflage doesn't hide an animal's presence, but merely misrepresents it.  Many fish species are similarly camouflaged.  Their vertical stripes may be brightly colored, which makes them stand out to predators, but when they swim in large schools, their stripes all meld together.  This confusing spectacle gives predators the impression of one big, swimming blob.  Another example of misrepresentation is the common trait of many animals, particularly fish, to have dark spot like markings on their tails.  A predator, expecting the fish to swim away in a forward direction, will move at a trajectory to intercept the fish in front of it.  If the fishÕs tail looks like its head, it can often easily get away.

 

Photo by Prizm

Many tropical fish use their coloration in combination with evasive tactics to avoid predators.[12]

 

A related camouflage tactic is for an animal to take on the appearance of some other object.  One of the most famous examples of this sort of impressionist is the walking stick, an insect that looks like an ordinary twig.  A predator can easily distinguish a walking stick from its surroundings, but the predator thinks itÕs only a stick, and ignores it.  You can also see this sort of camouflage in some Katydid species, which have evolved so that they look just like tree leaves.  Many leaf insects so closely resemble the green leaves of a tree, with their shape, markings and movements that other insects have been so deceived that they have actually nibbled on the insect.  Many of such animals also have an uncanny ability to remain motionless for extended periods of time, adding to the impression that they are a part of the backdrop.

 

Photo courtesy Scott Camazine

Walking sticks have adapted to resemble their surroundings. Most of the time, their predators pass them by as they would a real twig.

 

Photo courtesy Carl Rossler

A leafy sea dragon, photographed off the coast of Australia. Leafy sea dragons have developed flowing appendages and vivid coloration that lets them blend in with the undersea plant life in their environment.

 

Other animals use a more aggressive sort of mimicry.  Several moth species have developed striking designs on their wings that resemble the eyes of a larger animal.  The back of the Hawk Moth Caterpillar actually looks like a snakeÕs head, a frightening visage for most predators the moth would come across.  A simpler variation on this adaptation is simple color mimicry.  In many ecosystems, smaller poisonous animals develop a bright coloration.  Predators learn to steer clear of these colors, lest they get a mouthful of venom.  Over time, non-poisonous species may develop the same coloration, cashing in on the nasty reputation of the poisonous species.

 

Mimicry is a different approach than ordinary camouflage, but it works toward the same end. By developing a certain appearance, an animal species makes itself a harder target for predators and a sneakier hunter for prey. In different areas around the world, you'll see all sorts of variations and combinations on the basic elements of camouflage. As animal species evolve, they become more and more in tune with their environment. Often, these sorts of adaptations are more effective survival tools than an animal's more aggressive weapons of defense (teeth, claws, beaks). After all, being entirely overlooked by a predator is preferable to having to put up a fight.

 

Conclusion

There are a variety of means for animals to use their environment, the abilities of the senses of other animals in their eco-system, and physical properties of light, to produce an effective means of camouflage.  Some types of camouflage need very specific situations occurring in their specific niche to be effective.  Others are much more flexible and can work well in a variety of situations.  Camouflage is an essential part of every animalÕs existence and a fascinating subject of study.

 

 



[1] Page 189-190 Seeing The Light; Falk, Brill, Stork

[2] SnellÕs Law – Page 53 Seeing The Light; Falk, Brill, Stork

[3] Page 62-63 Seeing The Light; Falk, Brill, Stork

[4] Imagine trying to see red lines on a map while looking at it using a red light bulb.  Although the red lines may not appear different, if the background of the map was white, they would seem to have disappeared because the area surrounding the red lines would too be red.

[5]http://www.clarku.edu/departments/biology/biol201/CSantos/Chromatophores.htm

[6] Page 63 Seeing The Light; Falk, Brill, Stork

[7] http://members.ozemail.com.au/~feen/pb_old.html

[8] Info on melanin: http://www.britannica.com/eb/article?tocId=9051870

[9] Info on cuttlefish:

http://www.tonmo.com/articles/basiccuttlefish.php

http://www.heptune.com/cutfish.html

[10] A process of color mixing whereby small separate sources of various colors are placed close to each other.  If the eye cannot see them separately, the colors mix additively. Page 63 Seeing The Light; Falk, Brill, Stork

 

[11] http://www.photovault.com/Link/Animals/Aquatic/lGastropods/Nudibranch.html

[12] http://www.heavenly-creatures.net/xinher/archive/003765.html